UFO Conjecture(s)

Monday, July 25, 2016

Ufologists and the Thread of Madness

It’s obvious that there has always been a streak of madness in society and among humans, even from the very beginning of humankind.

Michel Foucault in Madness: The Invention of an Idea [HarperPerennial/ModernThought, NY, 1954/1962/1976], Part II, Madness and Culture deals with shamanistic choices and activity among native American Indian tribes.
Writing about the Zunis, Pueblos, Kwakiutl, Crows, et al., he zeroes in on the Berdaches of the Dakota Indian tribes who gave a religious status to homosexuals as priests and magicians, making them shamans accordingly. [Page 101 ff.]

Now is that madness? Yes, it’s a kind of societal madness, but such “madness” goes back much further than the studies by Durkheim who saw such odd deviance as a “morbid phenomenon.” [ibid]

It’s blatant, for those who pay attention to news media, that today’s society is as primitive, maybe more so, than that of early man, and the madness, while slightly more subtle than what we know from history, is ripe and ongoing: parents careless with their children, racism, indiscriminate murders, entertainments replacing altruistic or meaningful activities, and dozens of other behavioral malfeasances that seem like ignorance but are, indeed, threads of madness.

Both Freud and Jung, and many contemporary psychologists have addressed the issue of today’s psychopathology, but that for another time.

My point is that madness is almost an instinct in mankind. And it permeates the UFO subculture as rampantly as overt society but shows up in subliminal ways.

In ufology, one need only look at the commentary left at UFO blogs, web-sites, or the discussions at conferences and other UFO get-togethers.

The use of non de plumes or avatars by UFO buffs tells us a lot about readers and commentators in the UFO community.

Take a look at one of my favorite blogs – Kevin Randle’s; you’ll see intelligent postings by Mr. Randle, subsumed by inane, seeming ignorant ramblings by his followers, most using avatarial adjuncts. But underneath the ramblings lie indications of psychopathologies: paranoia, wishful thinking, outright deviations from facts and truth, et cetera.

Such carefree madness isn’t confined to Kevin’s blog. It is rampant across the UFO spectrum and not just limited to men, young or old, but also ingrained in women, i.e., Leslie Gunther, PurrlGurrl, among them.

In the desire to make the 1964 Socorro incident an ET (extraterrestrial incursion), UFO buffs have created a fantastic panoply of ifs and buts to make an almost prosaic happening into an alien incursion that is atypical of other supposed UFO events.
The ET premise came about by the “investigation” of one Ray Stanford, an ET believer whose bias has afflicted the Zamora episode to its core, exacerbated by UFO buffs who, to this day, see Police Officer Lonnie Zamora’s unique observation as confirmation that Earth has been visited by an alien species in an egg-shaped craft.

The underlying need to insert alien beings into the muck and mire of human society is as ignorant, er mad, as the idea that gods descended to Earth in its earliest days and communed with men (and women), leaving no discernible evidence or help that would alleviate human ills.

Yet, today, UFO buffs, such as Ben Moss, Anthony Mugan, Neal Foy, and others, see the Socorro incident as resplendent as that of the Old Testament prophets (and madmen).

Of course, UFO madness isn’t as egregious as that being displayed by such insane groups as ISIS, nowadays, or those of lone madmen who shoot innocent people going about their mad pleasures.

But it is madness just the same. And a kind of madness that is insidious in its own ways, replacing logic and intelligent sense with cockeyed ruminations that take us nowhere but closer to a human nervous breakdown, or mental calamity, as Freud warned in Civilization and Its Discontents and Jung in his Civilization in Transition.



  • RR,

    "But underneath the ramblings lie indications of psychopathologies: paranoia, wishful thinking, outright deviations from facts and truth, et cetera."

    You come right up to it but stumble into its depression. It's a numbers game. The vast majority of folk are normal and going about their business while the few bad guys are out there. Problem is with the exploding population the percentages are probably about the same.

    As a thoughtful blogger with digressions, you present this blog that I read daily, rejecting the avatar people and those of similar madness, presenting a thoughtful topics for consideration.

    The separation you provide is the old apples and oranges comparison.

    If we venture past our topic and consider ISIS, Hitler, Pol Pot and the like -or go off in the antithesis of God, Bible and etc, here or elsewhere it a a path the irreconcilable madness.

    If instead we focus on the the topic and the science there it is a pleasing consideration of the math, distances, percentages and etc., the limits of our science, and human observational issues... Choose that path and we can explore further and/or wait for discovery.

    Oh, and every time I read of Jung its like reading the Bible and seeing quotes that apply as those who quote scripture as proof of their position -But I must say I sometimes find it enjoyable anyway, Jung that is, not Bible.

    Back to topic Socorro, despite the conflicting evidence, its proximity to White Sands, the Hughes like emblem, and other considerations is still a head scratcher -but far back like Roswell. It would be nice if a technical document came up that said lander test group got a bit off track and just stopped for lunch briefly...


    By Blogger Bryan Daum, at Wednesday, July 27, 2016  

  • Bryan...

    You know I luv ya, but I have to disagree with one comment of yours: "The vast majority of folk are normal ..."

    On a scale from totally insane to moral/ethical certitude, "folk" would fall somewhere in the middle I think. And that could be called "normal."

    But you know me. I take a harsher more sensationalized position, about almost everything. (I"m not normal myself.)

    It's the subtlety of pathology that smacks me in the face, the thread of madness.

    I'll be presenting substantiating material about my position upcoming.

    As for Socorro, take a look at the comments ongoing at Kevin's blog. They are rife with insane-like observations and obsessional ramblings, almost as bad as those usually coming during a Roswell retread.

    Kevin drives me nuts by reopening these old cases, as he has an audience ready to pounce like hyenas going after a slab of meat.

    The nuts come out of the UFO woodwork and rehash arguments that have been marmoreal for years now.

    That's why ufology is so screwed up, but you know this.

    I'm a voice crying in the wilderness about this.


    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Wednesday, July 27, 2016  

  • RR,

    You got me there, on the "insane to moral/ethical certitude" scale, surely more of the bell shaped curve. Another aspect is the net gives an easy platform for the greatly uniformed as well as the zealots disproportionately.

    I also recall the early days of email descending into a current of forwarded jokes.


    By Blogger Bryan Daum, at Wednesday, July 27, 2016  

  • Yah, Bryan...

    Madness often takes the easy route(s).

    I'm just surprised at how Kevin's blog seems to act like flypaper for the UFO crazies. (He's so circumspect.)


    By Blogger RRRGroup, at Wednesday, July 27, 2016  

  • A madman uses his genius destructively, but a genius uses his madness constructively.

    By Blogger AudioMonk, at Monday, August 01, 2016  

Post a Comment

<< Home